Call Now: 814-218-3313 or 814-218-6259
Welcome to the Magic Cookie Company Bake Shoppe
Homemade Cookies Since 2005!
Where Delicious Delights Disappear!

Freshly Baked Magical Cookies

Who doesn't love BIG, CHUNKY, CHEWY, OOOOOOHY, GOOOOEY,
Lip Smacking and tummy tantalizing cookies?
Well you've come to the right place! 
The Magic Cookie Company Bake Shoppe.  We are famous for ours. 
Truly the BEST Cookies you've ever eaten for sure. Erie's Best Cookies-Magic Cookies!

Unlike a store-bought, machine-driven cookie, "Magic Cookies" are hand mixed, cut, scooped and packaged every day.  Our recipes are decades older then the bakery itself, and have been bassed down from generation to generation.  Crispy on the outside and the soft, chewy inside gives
you the best of both worlds in one gourmet indulgence!

No other cookies can compare.  In fact, "Magic Cookies" are so good, you don't even need milk! 
Everyone loves our cookies! Once you've tasted our "Magic Cookies" we are confident
that you will agree they are wellworth the extra special care and time we put into them.

You can definitely taste the homemade cookie goodness with every bite!
Share "Magic Cookies" with someone you love today. Dessert will never be the same!

Are you looking for delivery or pickup in Erie, PA?
Call us for the best prices!
Order our Magic Cookies for all your holiday parties, and social gatherings!

Homestyle Regular size cookies-$6.00 dozen
Homestyle Party Size cookies-$3.50 dozen
Speciality Cookies-Please call for prices vary



WE ASK THAT ALL ORDERS BE MADE AT LEAST 48 HOURS IN ADVANCE OF YOUR EVENT.
FOR LARGER MORE DETAILED ORDERS PLEASE CALL IN ADVANCE OF AT LEAST TWO WEEKS AHEAD.

We are a small family bake shoppe, we are willing to do
Big things for you.  All we ask is for your corrporation.


Cookie Trays
Cookie Mugs
Cookie Pizzas
Cookie Gifts

Our Magical Cookie Portfolio

Winter
Spring/Summer
Icecream 
Fall
Thanksgiving
Cookies for Santa
  1. Oatmeal Raisin Butterschotch
    Oatmeal Raisin Butterschotch
  2. Chocolate Chip
    Chocolate Chip
  3. Peanut Butter
    Peanut Butter
  4. Triple Chocolate
    Triple Chocolate
  5. White Chocolate Walnut
    White Chocolate Walnut
  6. Lemondoodle
    Lemondoodle
  7. Sugar
    Sugar
  8. The Cookie Man
    The Cookie Man
  9. Snickerdoodle
    Snickerdoodle
  10. Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
    Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
  11. Chocolate Peanut Butter
    Chocolate Peanut Butter
  12. Cookie Dough
    Cookie Dough
  13. Peanut Butter Kisses
    Peanut Butter Kisses
  14. Pecan Sandie
    Pecan Sandie
  15. M&Ms
    M&Ms
  16. Chocolate M&Ms
    Chocolate M&Ms
  17. Very Berry Breakfast
    Very Berry Breakfast
  18. Cookie of the Month
    Cookie of the Month
  19. Oatmeal Cinnamon
    Oatmeal Cinnamon
  20. Cookies N' Cream
    Cookies N' Cream
  21. Chocolate Cookies N' Cream
    Chocolate Cookies N' Cream
  22. Peanut Butter Reese's
    Peanut Butter Reese's
  23. Chocolate Reese's Pieces
    Chocolate Reese's Pieces
  24. Birthday
    Birthday
Cookies are made from the finest ingredients without preservatives. Each is cookie is individually wrapped for freshness. They are best consumed within 7 days. Cookies may also be frozen to prolong freshness. Thaw at room temperature.

Allergy Warning: Baked in a facility that processes products that contain peanuts, wheat, eggs and tree nuts.

No Refunds/Returns Are Accepted on Perishable Items